Search our news, events & opinions

On 1 September 2016 Withy King LLP merged with Royds LLP. The trading name for the merged firm is Royds Withy King. All content produced prior to this date will remain in the name of the firms pre-merger.

3 January 2014 0 Comments
Posted in Employment, Opinion

Dismissals – Inconsistency in decisions

Author headshot image Posted by , Partner

The case of Scottish Prison Service v Laing is an interesting case about inconsistent decisions on dismissal by an employer.

The Claimant was a prison officer who was dismissed for gross misconduct, for witnessing an assault by a prison officer on a prisoner and failing to report it. The Tribunal found his dismissal to be unfair because another prison officer who had also witnesses the assault had successfully appealed against his dismissal to the Internal Dismissal Appeal Board. Hence there was an allegation of inconsistency in treatment between the two prison officers, one of whom had been dismissed and the other who had not, for witnessing the same incident.

The Respondent appealed and the EAT allowed the appeal on the basis that the Tribunal had substituted its own decision for that of the employer. On the basis of the facts, the officer who had successfully appealed his dismissal to the Internal Appeals Board had seen less of the incident than the Claimant in the current case. The EAT considered that the question before the Tribunal was whether the decision of the Internal Dismissal Appeal Board was irrational; which it considered that it was not, because of the difference in what the two officers witnessed. Effectively, the EAT is saying that where there are cases of inconsistency, the employer’s decision will only be regarded as outside the range of reasonable responses if the decision can be considered irrational; and this is quite a high test to past.

This legal update is provided for general information purposes only and should not be applied to specific circumstances without prior consultation with us.

For further details on any of the issues covered in this update please contact Gemma Ospedale, Partner in Employment on 020 7583 2222.

Leave a comment

Thank you for choosing to leave a comment. Please keep in mind that comments are moderated and please do not use a spammy keyword or a domain as your name or it will be deleted.





It pays to employ the right employment solicitor

Learn more


T: 020 7842 1496 (DDI)

Search our news, events & opinions