Birth injury negligence invariably raise fears for the future in any parent’s mind. Not uncommonly, parents worry about to what extent the injury their child suffered was avoidable, and if things could have been different. Very sadly, parents often worry that what happened was in some way their fault.

In our experience, parents often feel uncomfortable about the prospect of litigation. But not infrequently, parents bring claims simply to get answers, and put their own minds at rest.

Shoulder dystocia (the condition that precedes Erb’s Palsy in the setting of birth) is a medical emergency. Sometimes it is unforeseeable. Many parents feel – understandably – that the clinicians who were present saved their child’s life by acting quickly and decisively. They are grateful, and don’t want to do anything that could cast blame on the individuals who were present.

Other parents view “compensation culture” with distaste. Still others believe they are taking money out of the system that could better be used on medical care.


If you want to find out more about the legal options available to you, please join us for one of our free online legal clinics in the week commencing 22 October 2018, from which you will receive a free legal report. You can find out more and register for it here.


Whilst this is entirely understandable, six things need to be kept in mind:

1. As shown in recent academic studies, Erb’s palsy is largely preventable through proper, rigorous training by maternity units;

2. As a result, a severe brachial plexus injury is quite possibly a sign of a lack in quick-thinking and clinical skill;

3. If an Erb’s Palsy claim is brought, the focus will rarely fall on the clinicians involved, but rather on their employer. These claims are almost always dealt with from a management and training point of view. Claims seek to understand where a whole system has broken down, rather than point blame at one individual. When there are adverse consequences for a child, it’s not unreasonable for that child’s family to be entitled to find a solution;

4. If you make a claim, you won’t be taking money that would otherwise be used for clinical care out of the system – there is a central fund that is set aside for compensation arising from clinical negligence claims;

5. It is arguably more socially responsible to bring a claim than not. This may sound counter-intuitive. However, by making a claim you are potentially bringing to light significant failings in how a hospital deals with shoulder dystocia. If you don’t raise it as a concern, it could happen to other children and their families. If the claim succeeds, then it is usually possible to receive care funded on a private basis. By extension, you are freeing up precious NHS time and resources for other people.

6. Sometimes, even when mothers do decide to bring a claim, they focus heavily (and rightly so) on the injury to their child, forgetting about any maternal injuries they may have suffered during childbirth. Maternal birth injuries often occur at the same time as Erb’s Palsy, and it’s important for mothers to ensure their claim reflects their own experience as well as their child’s.


Birth injuries affect families in a number of very complex ways. But we believe that by sensitively helping people to get closer to their answers, our medical negligence lawyers can help people understand what happened, and hopefully enable them to move forward, together.


If you’d like to register for one of our free online legal clinic taking place in the week commencing 22 October 2018, and the chance for a free legal report, please fill out the following form. Alternatively, click here to find out more.


Full name*

Email*

Phone number

When would you like to attend?

Please note that this is a public forum (visible to other users of the forum, the legal and medical experts and to the host of the chat forum provider FlyZoo. By entering your contact details to create an account and upon entering the forum, your personal information and any information you input into the forum will be visible to everyone in the forum. Please bear this in mind when considering the level of detail and sensitivity of the information you choose to share in this forum. [We suggest that you use a pseudonym when using the chat forum to protect your personal information].

Royds Withy King is the trading name of Withy King LLP. We are authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority, registration number 557896. We have specialist medical negligence solicitors who may be able to assist you with legal claims relating to Erb’s Palsy. By entering the forum, you can ask questions of the medical expert and/or are welcome to explore possible legal options with our legal experts, but are under no obligation to do so.

As the subject of the forum is Erb’s Palsy, a medical condition, the data shared within the forum is likely to include special category data for the purposes of the General Data Protection Regulation (“GDPR”) and we require your consent to process that data. Please see Royds Withy King’s privacy policy and the chat provider FlyZoo’s privacy policy to understand how your data may be used.

Please tick the box here to agree to that processing and to enter the forum.

We will only use data from this form for the purposes of this clinic.